37 Comments /

My top 30 anime

I had a sud­den shock­ing real­isa­tion: In the 19 months that I’ve been blab­bing away about anime I’ve never made a post where I spe­cific­ally out­line my favour­ite ones. Gen­er­ally that’s one of the first things I do when I talk to any­one who’s an anime fan or the first thing I look for on an anime blog. It gives you an instant insight into what that per­sons taste and pref­er­ences are. Quite often you don’t even read what they have to say about each anime (which is why I’ve left each descrip­tion rel­at­ively shot). So here we go, here’s my top 30 anime.

Some notes before I start: I’m includ­ing anime that I’ve seen enough of to know where they’re pos­i­tion in this list is. Obvi­ously this will change with time as I watch more and also rewatch those in my top 30. Finally, an hon­our­able men­tion goes out to Seto no Hanayome, Kino’s Jour­ney, Bake­monogatari, Haibane Rem­nei and Grave of the Fire­flies, who both just missed out on mak­ing this list.

30: Dur­arara

While not as good as its spir­itual pre­de­cessor, Bac­cano, Dur­arara is still a massive romp and huge fun through­out. The way the city of Ikebukero is por­trayed is fant­astic. We have sev­eral dif­fer­ent demi-gods, deit­ies and demons wan­der­ing around as humans, inter­act­ing and com­pet­ing with one another as mere humans walk amongst them. Heaven for­bid should these humans get ideas above their sta­tion and com­pete with them on level terms.

29: Nodame Can­tabile (first season)

Mukya~! The whole series is such fun but what I love about it is the way Nodame and Chiaki are drawn to each other des­pite being total opposites…no, because they’re total oppos­ites. The total hon­esty and goof­ing about of Nodame con­trast­ing with the hard­work­ing tsun­dere atti­tude of Chiaki. They play off each other fant­ast­ic­ally. I love ‘em to bits, Gyabo~!

28: Moy­ashi­mon

Fic­tion never quite por­trays life real­ist­ic­ally. In my exper­i­ence, real life is a lot weirder with more wilder char­ac­ters with more unusual thoughts going through their head. It may be an odd to call Moy­ashi­mon a real­istic look at uni­ver­sity life when there are cute bac­teria fly­ing all over the place, but it’s the accept­ance of the unusual in Moy­ashi­mon that really drew me in. That, and it’s really, really funny.

27: Hell­sing

Yep, the ori­ginal, manga-mangled ver­sion of Hell­sing. I can cer­tainly see why people may not like this but I say fuck them, this show is one of the most ass-kickingly piece of con­cen­trated awe­some­ness in anime his­tory. Bril­liantly vicious dia­logue, hot hard-line Brit­ish women (WATCH THE DUB), and the Vam­pire to end all Vam­pires. Alu­card you sad­istic freak. You made that show.

26: Pale Cocoon

Nor­mally when it comes to anime shorts, I’m a harsh grader. Unless they do some­thing truly unique and mind­blow­ing then I’ll give it a crap score. Maybe part of that reason why is because of Pale Cocoon. Every short I watch from now on always get that unfor­tu­nate label of being ‘nowhere near as good as Pale Cocoon’. Holds the record for the single best short in anime his­tory. That very last frame as the real­isa­tion sets in. Just…watch it.

25: Black Lagoon: Second Barrage

Not that the first sea­son wasn’t awe­some or any­thing, it’s just it was totally swept away by the second. Everything the first did the second did bet­ter. A bet­ter focus of the true hor­rors of Roanapur, a greater cast of the true wild­cards that inhabit that devil city. OK, the first sea­son man­aged the Rock/Revy rela­tion­ship bet­ter, but Roanapur is the real reason to watch this anime. You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy.

24: Neon Gen­esis Evangelion

Evan­gelion is an odd one. It wasn’t until the end that I real­ised how little I under­stood about the plot and that never under­stood the sym­bol­ism. Yet, as you can see from its inclu­sion in here, I loved the thing. A true sense of cine­ma­to­graphy epicry (I made that word up) com­bined with that ever-growing sense of fear and mind­fuck­ery endured by the main char­ac­ters was what I truly enjoyed about this classic.

23: Full Metal Panic (first season)

Full Metal Panic is a great to use to intro­duce a friend to the world of anime. Not only is it hugely enter­tain­ing, very access­ible, well-written and all-round fun, it’s the most fun­da­ment­ally ‘anime’ title out there. The mecha, the aqua­mar­ine hair, the tsun­dere, the wacky com­edy, and all of these things are done bet­ter here than you’ll find pretty much any­where else. If your friend doesn’t like Full Metal Panic, chances are anime is not for them.

22: Ghost in the Shell:

Stand Alone Complex

Pro­duc­tion IG, you sure are cap­able of some amaz­ing work when you put your mind to it. While the Ghost in the Shell Movie may have been all about human­ity and so on, it was the intrec­ate plot­ting of Stand Alone Com­plex that I loved. I would spend just as long dis­cuss­ing the pos­sibile plot dir­ec­tions as I did watch­ing the actual epis­odes them­selves. Laugh­ing Man, how bloody long did I spend the­or­iz­ing over your existance I’d prefer not to remember.

21: Arakawa Under the Bridge

Arakawa is a com­edy I can get behind but the true genius isn’t in the com­edy. Oh sure, it’s funny. End­lessly so. It has Sis­ter, a trig­ger happy, war vet­eran dressed as a nun. But what really makes this show is the intel­li­gence behind its con­struc­tion. The story is so per­fectly done and the way it wraps in on itself, col­lapsing Recruit’s world in on him­self and build­ing up the new world as he learns what he really wants in life might not be what com­mon sense tells him what he needs. Besides, what’s com­mon sense anyway.

20: Detroit Metal City

God­dam you DMC. You do real­ise that you’ve ruined music for me forever? I mean, it’s under­stand­able why I can no longer take heavy metal music ser­i­ously, and any rock music by asso­ci­ation, but now I can’t take that happy music ser­i­ously either. I’m expect­ing halfway through the chorus for the main singer to sud­denly stop jig­gling his tam­bour­ine and start rap­ing it. GO TO DMC!

19: Ten­gen Toppa Gur­ren Lagann

If there’s a wall in our way, we’ll des­troy it! If there’s no road, we’ll pave it with our own hands! Your drill is the drill that will pierce the heav­ens! Don’t believe in the me who believes in you. Don’t believe in the you who believes in me, believe in your­self! Go bey­ond the impossible and kick reason to the curb! WHO THE HELL DO YOU THINK WE ARE!!!

18: Full Metal Alchemist

After delib­er­a­tion, I’ve decided to simply lump both the ori­ginal and Broth­er­hood together. Broth­er­hood has reminded me, both through its strengths and through its faults, why the ori­ginal Full Metal Alchem­ist was such a good story. This is shounen at its finest. Well, it would be if you could com­bine the pacing of the first series with the sense of epic tim­ing (like comedic tim­ing, except with *phwoar* instead of laughs) then you’d have the per­fect shounen.

17: Eden of the East

Mar­gin­ally super­ior to his efforts on Ghost in the Shell, Kam­iyama really knows how to set my mind in motion. No other anime made me con­coct such wild the­or­ies for pos­sible dir­ec­tions in the plot only to later shove it in my face that I’d picked up a red her­ring. Noblesse Oblige. Please get me one of those mes­siah phones with Juiz’s voice.

16: Cow­boy Bebop

For what is con­sidered in many quar­ters to be the greatest anime ever cre­ated, it sure does start of very slow. The first epis­odes, while still good, were nowhere near as good as I anti­cip­ated it would be. It star­ted to turn around epis­ode 8 but it wasn’t until epis­ode 13 when it finally hit me. As the cred­its rolled down the screen with the song ‘Space Lion’ play­ing, it finally dawned on me why. This truly is one of the greatest anime of all time.

15: Kaiba

Quite often when it comes to these poncy, artsy anime I just find myself rolling my eyes at the des­per­ate attempts to prove that they are dif­fer­ent from the norm. In fact, I did that in Kaiba some­times too. But what I was treated to bey­ond the Dr.Seass style art­work was a mas­ter­class in storytelling and ima­gin­a­tion. Power­ful and beau­ti­ful, this turned me into an instant Yuasa fan.

14: Akira

You know, they don’t make anime like they used to. Where is that level of viol­ence and depth and dis­sect­able fea­tures that was pre­val­ent in anime back in the good old days. When is the last time we’ve seen a truly adult anime take the west­ern world by storm. When was…what am I say­ing, I wasn’t even alive when that happened. So shut up you old­f­ags, stop scar­ing away the new­f­ags and let them enjoy Akira for what it is.

13: Love Hina

Yes, I did just go from Cow­boy Bebop, Kaiba and Akira to Love Hina. I’ll admit, there is more than just a touch of nos­tal­gia for my gate­way to anime. But there’s more than that. When the moun­tains of harems that came after tried copy­ing his loser arche­type, they for­got to take the real aspect that makes him easy to relate to: hon­esty. Often to my det­ri­ment, I believe in the good­will in human­kind and Keit­aro is that per­son­i­fied. Chiv­alry is alive and well.

12: Cro­martie High School

The abso­lute fun­ni­est fuck­ing thing in exist­ence. When writ­ing about Cro­martie High School, even the memory of the show sets me into a fit of giggles. Argu­ably the single greatest first epis­ode (and final epis­ode, by asso­ci­ation) in anime his­tory, I knew I would love this show as soon as that ran­dom thug placed that pen­cil inside his mouth. He.…ate.…my.…pencil.…HE ATE MY PENCIL!

11: Samurai Champloo

It’s not often that you can pin down the exact moment you were sold on a par­tic­u­lar anime. Often it’s just a gradual feel­ing but when it does hap­pen, usu­ally it’s sev­eral epis­ode in (in Bebop, Champloo’s sis­ter series, it took until epis­ode 13). For Samurai Champloo, it was about 4 minutes into the first epis­ode with that timeskip scene. This was a show try­ing to be the coolest thing ever and suc­ceed­ing spectacularly.

10: Last Exile

This is why I miss Gonzo. They were cap­able of glor­i­ous cre­ations like Last Exile. This was one of those per­fect adven­ture anime in which everything seemed to be tailored to my tastes. Never stayed too long on a cer­tain plot point, fant­astic ima­gin­a­tion to cre­ate that world of Anat­oray and Disith, a fant­astic open­ing song and CGI incor­por­ated prop­erly. This is why I watch anime. Because the make series like Last Exile.

9: Hare + Guu

It leaves me a rather depressed guy to see this show get so little love. On the other hand if every­one else loved it, I wouldn’t be able to use this as my token series to use pic­tures of for my forum and pro­file pic­tures. So why do I love this anime? Guu. Guu is a comedic queen, not just in her own right, but how she can twist any situ­ation to her lik­ing. Some­times it takes noth­ing more than a grin to warp the mind of poor Hare.

8: School Rumble

Greatest cast of char­ac­ters ever. If I was ever to make a true my dream harem post, it would con­sist of about half the cast of this series (but not Temna). It must have been such an easy thing to write this series once the char­ac­ters were formed. All you needed was for some­thing to hap­pen and then think ‘ok, who would be the fun­ni­est out of our extens­ive cast of fant­astic char­ac­ters to place in this scene?’. And so you get Har­ima being hit in the face with a mop.

7: Ber­serk

Ber­serk is flaw­less. There’s not one mis­step through­out the entire series. No scene is shown without it hav­ing mean­ing. No twist is intro­duced without prior fore­shad­ow­ing. Never once did the pacing drop or get too fast. Not once did a someone act out of char­ac­ter and their devel­op­ment all worked nat­ur­ally. It all wraps in on itself to cre­ate one bril­liant story. Ber­serk is perfect.

6: Mushishi

Mushishi is a rare beast. It’s one of those very few times where prac­tic­ally every­one in anime fan­dom has stood back in col­lect­ive admir­a­tion for a single cre­ation. It’s one of those times where, while watch­ing it, you real­ise that you are watch­ing a mas­ter­piece. It’s a hard feel­ing to con­vey but there’s so many scenes, such as stand­ing under the rain­bow, the goopy-eye scene, the entirety of one-eyed fish, that it really hits you. This is the closest to per­fec­tion anime has ever achieved.

5: Gankut­suou

Want to show some­body what anime is truly cap­able of that no other medium of enter­tain­ment can prop­erly con­vey? Shove a copy of Gankut­suou in their faces and let them watch and be amazed. Like the rest of my top 10, this is one of those shows in which everything clicks. Topped off by our favour­ite homo­erotic Count, this para­graph is yet another let­ter mourn­ing the loss of Gonzo in the anime world.

4: Chob­its

For ages after watch­ing Love Hina I searched for a series that was able to mir­ror that exper­i­ence of my first anime but all those com­pared to it were shitty fanser­vice harem knock-offs. I might have even stopped watch­ing anime until Chob­its came along. Chob­its ignited what before was a near non-existent romantic side to me. It made me believe. It made me believe that, even in the most extraordin­ary of cir­cum­stances, love over­comes all boundaries.

3: Code Geass

Are you not enter­tained? Is this not why you are here? This is Code Geass, the series with the hon­our of giv­ing the name to this glor­i­ous web­site, yet even this site is but a small shrine to a single second char­ac­ter in the almighty encom­passing cre­ation of the Code Geass uni­verse. Do not be fooled, this anime will not be for­got­ten in the com­ing years. A mod­ern clas­sic in every sense of the word, I’ll make sure of that myself.

2: Bac­cano

Bac­cano is dis­tilled enter­tain­ment. This was 16 epis­odes of pure, unadul­ter­ated and migh­tily viol­ent enter­tain­ment. Psy­chos boun­cing off other psy­chos while the lesser nut­ters get out-nutted by the wilder folks as the crazed kids fight the sud­den her­oes and mass destruc­tion on a small scale. There is no good and evil. Only nut­ters, and that’s how I like it.

1: Death Note

Yeah, this is a really bor­ing choice as num­ber one isn’t it. It’s the most pop­u­lar series on MAL and the most com­mon one to rank inside peoples top 5. So why is it my num­ber 1? Because it gave me the rush. It gave me a feel­ing of sheer energy and enthu­si­asm, as though there was noth­ing in my life that could pos­sibly be more exhil­ar­at­ing than watch­ing what was on my screen.

::Update No.1 on 19\7\10:: Seto no Hanayome, Kino’s Jour­ney and Bake­monogatari dropped out to be replaced by Ber­serk, Arakawa Under the Bridge and Durarara

This entry was posted in Top 30 Anime and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

35 Comments

  1. luffyluffy
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 6:54 pm | Permalink

    I’m not going to lie, if it wasnt for Cow­boy Bebop, I prob­ably wouldnt be here typ­ing away on this blog~

    Spike you sexy beast, I fangirled so hard over you.. I also met Steve Blum, god what a day that was XD

    BACCANO WAS SO AMAZING, I WATCHED IT TWICE IN THE SAME MONTH. Evan­gelion was.. ehh~ Death Note I find pre­ten­tious sorta, Geass was spoiled for me, still need to fin­ish Kino’s Jour­ney and Gankut­stou, and MUSHISHI WAS FANTASTIC. NUFF SAID.

  2. Posted February 17, 2010 at 7:04 pm | Permalink

    going through the list i was like “yes this list is awe­some” then i came to the #1 XD

    still an awe­some list des­pite my per­sonal dis­like for DN :P

  3. Posted February 17, 2010 at 7:17 pm | Permalink

    I just real­ized I have yet to make on these list myself on my blog. Huh.

    Such a great list though. So many good things.

  4. Posted February 17, 2010 at 7:19 pm | Permalink

    I swear, these posts are like the best thing for gath­er­ing info on the blogger’s tastes…

    The first thing that popped in my head was that your tastes are rather main­stream. My other thoughts are some­where along the lines of you valu­ing enter­tain­ment above all else within a series, isn’t picky on where that enter­tain­ment derives from (but mostly action/wacko-comedy), loves eye candy, and require at least a mod­er­ately fast pacing.

  5. Scamp
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 7:49 pm | Permalink

    @luffyluffy

    It’s hard not to be spoiled for Geass. Heck, even this web­site by its very existance could be a spoiler, except I des­per­ately try to keep any Geass spoil­ers when talk­ing about the name

    @chii

    Huh, DN is pop­u­lar amongst annoy­ing emo kids (who make up a huge pro­por­tion of anime fan­dom) and weirdos like me.

    @Janette

    If K-ON is on that list of yours.….

    @Aorii

    The main­stream thing is some­thing I wish I didn’t have. I really do try to watch obscure anime as well and have a list as crazy and diverse as psgels from Star Crossed but I always end up pref­fer­ing the pop­u­lar stuff. They’re pop­u­lar for a reason I guess.

    Oth­er­wise you’re pretty much right. Fast pacing isn’t a pre-requisite but definately preffered

  6. Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:15 pm | Permalink

    @Scamp i am aware at how “pop­u­lar” DN is. that doesn’t mean *I* have to like it ;)

  7. Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:17 pm | Permalink

    Awe­some, it’s nice to see some love for Kaiba. Yet another series with a lot of good going for it that got lost in the shuffle.

    Look­ing at your list, I real­ize exactly how much anime I need to get watched at some point. I’ve heard of everything on the list, but I haven’t even seen half of it. Time to get to work I guess…

  8. Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:22 pm | Permalink

    Guu is one of anime’s greatest assholes. I like in com­edy when writers are unafraid to make a char­ac­ter an enorm­ous prick and be com­pletely unapo­lo­getic about it without feel­ing the need to soften up that char­ac­ter and make ‘em sym­path­etic or whatever. I don’t want to sym­path­ize with Guu; I want to laugh at her mak­ing poor Hare’s life a liv­ing hell! (Tomo from Azu­manga Daioh is like this for me, too, but even she is nowhere as huge an asshole as Guu.)

    The Roberta storyline from the first sea­son is my favor­ite from Black Lagoon, but over­all I’d agree the second sea­son is super­ior to the first. Balalaika is the scar­i­est woman ever.

    Maybe I’ll start cob­bling together one of these posts pretty soon, too.

  9. luffyluffy
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:28 pm | Permalink

    No, like Scamp, Geass was spoiled so hard for me, that there was no point in watch­ing it because I already knew what was going to happen.

    That didnt stop me for cry­ing for a good half an hour dur­ing the final epis­ode, and hit­ting my friend for laugh­ing at it XD

  10. vucubcaquix
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:28 pm | Permalink

    No FLCL makes me a little sad. Other than that, cool list bro. There are about six or so I haven’t seen yet that I have to get around to.

  11. Poro
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:44 pm | Permalink

    you spelled Dr. Seuss wrong TAT wow do I live in a dif­fer­ent era of anime or what.

  12. Posted February 17, 2010 at 8:58 pm | Permalink

    Back when all the blog­gers were post­ing their top 5 lists, I rarely saw Death Note. Maybe it’s because blog­gers have seen more anime than your typ­ical fan. Maybe it’s a sub­con­scious aver­sion to prais­ing any­thing main­stream. I’m guess­ing a little of both.

  13. Posted February 17, 2010 at 9:11 pm | Permalink

    Well, con­sid­er­ing the anime helped me get a boy­friend, I HAVE to include it. :P

  14. Scamp
    Posted February 17, 2010 at 9:16 pm | Permalink

    @Rakuen

    I’m happy with the level of praise Kaiba got. It was far too bizarre to ever get that much but it cer­tainly got enough praise to con­vince a fair few non-mainstream fans to watch it. Hop­ing that some­thing like Kaiba will ever be a big hit is stu­pid and all you can hope is that it becomes a cult hit. Which it pretty much did

    @Shinmaru

    Guu is joint top as my favour­ite char­ac­ter of all time along­side L. I think I inher­antly like char­ac­ters with short names or some­thing. My third favour­ite is Horo. But yeah, Guu is amazing.

    @luffyluffy

    The final epis­ode of Geass is the greatest anime end­ing of all time by a coun­try mile. Heck, I named this blog after the end­ing. If that doesn’t show my love for it then I don’t know what does

    @vucubcaquix

    I like FLCL a lot but it doesn’t make the list. I’ve seen a LOT of great anime. Although I’ve also seen a lot of ter­rible anime, such is the glor­i­ous diversity of this medium of enter­tain­ment we are all so enam­oured by

    @Poro

    Dif­fer­ent era? Are you talk­ing time­frame? These are all pretty evenly spread out over the last dec­ade. Are you an oldfag?

    @Baka-Raptor

    I’d assumed at the time that it was because the people doing those lists were all moef­ags but even when people with sim­ilar taste to me start­ing mak­ing those ‘best of the dec­ade’ lists there was a pain­ful lack of DN. They didn’t seem to have a prob­lem with put­ting in any other main­stream hit like Geass, Gur­ren Lagann, Haruhi etc. so I don’t think they’re against main­stream. Also unlike other shounen hits like Bleach it’s gen­er­ally very highly praised and well-rated. It seems to be restric­ted to anime bloggers.

    I guess they just have no taste

  15. Posted February 17, 2010 at 9:45 pm | Permalink

    Well, the gen­eral fan opin­ion of Death Note is that it is really good through the first two-thirds, and the final third takes a dip in qual­ity — the size of that dip is debated (I prob­ably like it more than a fair num­ber of people), but it is a dip non­ethe­less. I like Death Note’s end­ing, and all, but it’s a good end to a story that isn’t quite as good near the end as in the middle. So maybe that’s one reason why people don’t include it in their favorites.

    (Then again, that doesn’t really explain Code Geass being on favor­ites lists since Geass sea­son one vs. R2 caused a WAY big­ger shit­storm than did any decline in Death Note’s story. Maybe people just respon­ded to Geass more since it is more melo­dra­matic than Death Note — and that’s say­ing something!)

    For me per­son­ally Death Note is a good series, but I wouldn’t put it on my favor­ites list because it didn’t quite con­nect with me on the level I expect a favor­ite to do. It’s sim­ilar to Bac­cano! in that way — very enter­tain­ing, and I’m a def­in­ite fan, but it never formed that con­nec­tion with me.

    Dif­fer­ent people look for dif­fer­ent things, though. I cer­tainly won’t fault any­one for hav­ing Death Note on a favor­ites list.

  16. Posted February 17, 2010 at 9:55 pm | Permalink

    @Scamp
    I wasn’t imply­ing that Kaiba would ever go main­stream. That’d be about as crazy as say­ing every­one should go watch Ban­ner of the Stars ASAP. I’d rather wish that more people give it a chance. Per­haps that’s fool­ish as well, but I think we all secretly hope that someone will find our per­sonal cult clas­sics and enjoy them.

  17. Posted February 17, 2010 at 10:29 pm | Permalink

    I’m some­what irrit­ated by how few of these I’ve seen. Espe­cially as many of them are shows that every­one knows. And I have heard of most of them…=.=

    Death Note is a good show, but I don’t think I’d put it as num­ber one…I just didn’t feel that exhil­ar­ated by L’s ram­bling and Kira’s overly dra­matic moments of thought.

  18. Posted February 18, 2010 at 12:22 am | Permalink

    God­dam­mit. I told myself I’d avoid doing a “all-time favor­ite” list so soon after doing my “best of the dec­ade” stuff, but I wanna do one now. *shakes fist angrily*

    I’m ashamed to say I’ve never seen Kaiba or Mushishi. I need to get around to those two some­time soon. I’m also sur­prised to see Hare + Guu in someone’s top ten. It’s a pretty awe­some series (although I’ve only seen about half of it, need to rem­edy THAT too), but hardly any­one talks about it. Guu is insane and evil in all the right ways.

    The only series on your list that’d make me cry out “NO WAY NOT THAT!” is Love Hina, but I won’t argue against nos­tal­gia. I’m sure I’ll have a couple of nos­tal­gic choices on my own list.

  19. Posted February 18, 2010 at 1:23 am | Permalink

    This list is good and valid. I’ve seen most of these shows, but I will make an effort to see the ones I don’t like, because I don’t think that there’s a single show on this list that I’ve seen that I don’t like (except for Bake­monogatari, which I am strug­gling with, although I think I’m start­ing to like it more…I think).

    I thought that the second sea­son of FMP was 10000 times bet­ter than the first. But they were still both good.

  20. Monsturr
    Posted February 18, 2010 at 1:44 am | Permalink

    Wow, I… wasn’t actu­ally expect­ing to have seen so many of your favor­ites! I agree with nearly all of them, but I just have to say–

    Haibane Ren­mei. I can’t believe you’ve actu­ally seen it, for one. It’s prob­ably my all-time favor­ite anime, but nobody has actu­ally seen it, yet. You have! Incred­ible. After hear­ing all of your talk about how yuri anime are all just girls being nice to each other and how bor­ing that sort of thing is (…not that Haibane Ren­mei is yuri, obvi­ously), I never would’ve thought that you’d be able to sit through Haibane Ren­mei, since nearly all of it at the begin­ning is just that… on the sur­face, anyway.

    Would you mind telling me what you liked about Haibane Ren­mei? Or dis­liked. ‘Cause I’m just amazed, really, and I’d love to hear what you have to say about it.

  21. Scamp
    Posted February 18, 2010 at 2:22 pm | Permalink

    @Shinmaru

    I will admit that the last third is nowhere near as good as the first two. From a more object­ive point of view Bac­cano is prob­ably bet­ter. How­ever Death Note is my ‘favour­ite’ and there’s an import­ant dif­fer­ence there.

    @mefloraine

    It’s because I have main­stream tastes. There­fore, every­ones heard of the anime I love

    @Landon

    Mushishi has become a ‘must-watch’ in anime fan­dom by this stage, such is the level of praise it gets. I went into it think­ing ‘huh. stu­pid elit­ists’ and left think­ing ‘…wow’. It’s definately far removed from the usual ‘PHWOAR’ that most of my top 30 is made up of but that only adds to the power of my rec­comend­a­tion because it’s not some­thing I’d nor­mally love. So yeah, watch Mushishi

    @Glo

    This list has been Glo val­id­ated (trademark)

    @Monsturr

    True, Haibane Rem­nei isn’t the type of thing I usu­ally watch and I don’t like either of the other ABe works (Lain and Texyloyze) but Haibane is dif­fer­ent. It was one of those rare occa­sions where an anime has abso­lutely no flaws in its story-telling. It felt so well-constructed and there was so much lying under the sur­face. My favour­ite memory of Haibane was that I used to watch an epis­doe or two before I went to bed and, asides from send­ing my straight to sleep, I had the most unusual dreams.

  22. Posted February 18, 2010 at 5:52 pm | Permalink

    Coin­cid­ent­ally, I also recently real­ized that I never made a post about my favor­ite anime, so I went ahead and did that a few weeks ago (my top 50 though).

    Lots of great shows here. It’s nice to see Chob­its so high on your list. It doesn’t get the love it deserves among CLAMP’s other titles. And although it’s not my abso­lute favor­ite, Death Note is always a win­ner in my book (I think it was 11th on my list).

  23. Posted February 19, 2010 at 5:59 pm | Permalink

    I’m most impressed by how high Last Exile is ranked. For ages I always hear people said how mediocre it was espe­cially the end­ing but I never got that cause every time I watched it, it was per­fect :)

    (I’m late in com­ment­ing, again)

  24. kadian1364
    Posted February 19, 2010 at 8:08 pm | Permalink

    You like thrill­ing and high-octane, I like thought­ful and sen­ti­mental. Not that we’re exclus­ive about our pref­er­ences in anime or oth­er­wise, but that’s the trend I see between your top favor­ites and mine. And some­times there’s a show that com­bines the best of both worlds, and everybody’s happy.

  25. Scamp
    Posted February 19, 2010 at 9:02 pm | Permalink

    @Yumeka

    I’ve yet to really love any of the other Clamp titles (Geass doesn’t count) but I’ve only tried Kobato and XXXHolic. And hur­rah for some more Death Note love. This post has shown me how it seems to have remark­ably little love amongst the aniblogsphere

    @Canne

    I can see why someone who isn’t into that genre might not like Last Exile but it was basic­ally everything I love about anime packed into one title. It never amazed me entirely in any par­tic­u­lar area but was excel­lent in every area I cared about

    @kadian1364

    Yup, my anime men­tal­lity is very much ‘enter­tain me’, hence I’m not one for human drama. Thougt­ful how­ever I do appri­ci­ate although maybe not as much as you

  26. Leah-san
    Posted May 30, 2010 at 1:42 pm | Permalink

    Is Gankut­suou an Bishonen-Anime, like Hetalia? The pic­ture made me curi­ous. And the guy on the left looks like France. And he’s dressed like France. THERE ARE EVEN ROSES.
    And I’m watch­ing Hare+Guu now, thanks to you. It’s weird, yet awe­some. Poor Hare. The open­ing freaked me out. Dan­cing… palms… and the cats…

    • Scamp
      Posted May 30, 2010 at 1:51 pm | Permalink

      Yay, more people watch­ing Hare Guu! That can only be a good thing.

      Gankut­suou characters…well, I sup­pose they are very fab­ulous and stuff. It’s very artsy anim­a­tion so I never really noticed the bishie-ness of the char­ac­ter designs, although there is a hell of a lot of homo-erotic vibes from the whole thing

      • Leah-san
        Posted May 30, 2010 at 4:10 pm | Permalink

        Thats even bet­ter.
        After Hare+Guu, I’m so gonna watch this. There will never be enough fab­ulous homo­erotic France-Guys with roses for me.

        Oh, and Guu is now on my “Scary”-List on num­ber one, she topped Rus­sia. She’s also now my favour­ite anime girl, even before Osaka. And thats some­thing to top. Damn, one can never tell whats shes think­ing. And her bored expres­sion is awe­some. Thats the kind of… (what exactly is she?) I never want to meet, but enjoy to watch mak­ing every­ones life miserable.

      • Leah-san
        Posted May 31, 2010 at 6:38 pm | Permalink

        Oh, and want I also find quite good is that Hare sounds actu­ally like a boy and not like a girl with a little lower voice, even though he’s just 10 (But, I’m on to epis­ode 7 now and he’s 11)

  27. Marcus
    Posted June 8, 2010 at 1:40 pm | Permalink

    Why don’t you have Bleach on here?!? I swear I will hunt you down and kill you. Oh well, though, I think out of the animes on this list you were right to pick death note as num­ber 1. It’s sus­pense and watch­ing Kira and L, then Kira and Near duke it out was incred­ibly exhiler­at­ing. If you havn’t watched it, or will not watch it in the next 30 minutes, shame on you

  28. Posted July 19, 2010 at 10:38 am | Permalink

    Pale Cocoon is amaz­ing, espe­cially the very end. It’s on my Top 50 List.

  29. KJAY
    Posted July 29, 2010 at 5:53 am | Permalink

    2 weeks ago i looked at the list when seto no hanayome and kinos jour­ney were on the list, and i watched them both only to find they are off the list. Its all good tho cuz i saw dur­arara as well, and good choice for #1 and 3. Lel­ouche and Light are the best char­ac­ters but i dont really like their endings-let the bad guy win for once.

    • Scamp
      Posted July 29, 2010 at 9:14 pm | Permalink

      Tastes change over time. There’s always more anime to watch, wait­ing to get into this list.

      Aint anime fabulous~!

2 Trackbacks

  1. […] 17, 2010 by Janette Scamp did a list of his top 30 anime, which made me real­ize that I’ve never really com­plied such a […]

  2. […] The Cart Drive: http://thecartdriver.com/my-top-30-anime/ […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Subscribe without commenting

  • Categories

  • Anime

  • Affiliates

  • Aniblog Aggregators

  • Top Commenters

  • Archives

  • Other blog stuff