10 CommentsHunter X Hunter / By Shinmaru /

Hunter x Hunter 11 – Heart in a Bag

This is definitely the point where people who enjoyed the original Hunter x Hunter must stop hoping the remake will grow to be like the original. And, honestly, I am perfectly fine with that. (Having not read the manga, I of course cannot speculate on how close or far this show is striking to that, but I’d wager that people should stop having expectations there, too.)

The scene where Killua rips the heart out of the mass murderer’s chest is a prime example of the new Hunter x Hunter striking a different tone with the same material. On a practical level, the show airs in the morning in Japan — prime time for children — so of course the show cannot be too violent and bloody (though I think it’s kind of a small miracle that the show is as dark as it is). The way the remake stands at the precipice of violence while not diving headlong into it both keep the creators somewhat safe from potentially outraged parents and gives the violence a noticeably different tone than the original series, which fits in with how the remake has this weirdly lighthearted tone in what is kind of a fucked-up world.

Mostly I refer to the bag in which Killua keeps the mass murderer’s heart. In the original, Killua does basically the same thing, and the initial result is about as violent. However, the heart is also shown pumping away in full view, whereupon Killua just straight up crushes it into a bloody mess. To me, this is where the original and remake have something in common: This action, and the murderer’s reaction to it, comes off as darkly comic. The reaction to it is less “Wow, Killua just killed that man — he’s a murderer!” and more “HOLY FUCKING SHIT, HE RIPPED THAT GUY’S HEART OUT . . . AND IS IT STILL BEATING?! AHAHAHAHA”

This seems intentional. The guy’s heart continues to beat, and he actually reaches for it, as if getting the heart back into his body will keep him alive. And when the guy’s heart stops, he dies, too, as if there is still some sort of connection between him and his heart. That is some stone cold black humor right there; I laughed my ass off when I saw it for the first time, and I laughed here, too. And — this is where the bag comes in — I may have laughed more here. The very fact that Killua has a bag ready in which to deposit this dude’s heart is hilarious in and of itself. Again, as a practicality, the bag exists to hide the heart from the (presumably child-dominated) audience. But it adds another weird twist of humor to what is supposed to be a somber action.

Killua putting the bag back in the murderer’s palm is kind of hilarious, too. It’s less a sign of respect than it is Killua saying, “Yeah, I totally don’t need this stupid thing anymore. Here you go!” And then Killua immediately challenges the second-most dangerous opponent to come get some, and seems disappointed when he doesn’t take the bait. Oh, Killua, you are so delightfully bloodthirsty. But the funniest reaction of all is probably from Gon, who could not give less of a shit that his new best friend is a psychopathic murder, and immediately wants to pass the time with him by playing games. Gon, you are just as crazy as Killua.

Contrast this tone with the original series: While the heart-ripping has that somewhat humorous twist I wrote about earlier, it’s definitely played much more seriously. (You can watch it here if you’re curious. It’s at about 19:00 in the video.) The music is the track in the original series reserved for exciting, dangerous action. The “ohhhhhhhh fuuuuuuuuuuuck” reactions are drawn out just a bit more. And while the dialogue afterward is largely the same, Killua’s facial expressions and the way he is framed mark him less as a psychopathic, playful child (like the remake) and more as a badass in miniature. Much like most of the original, the same events are played off as more somber and serious. That’s the divide between the two series, and I doubt it will be something that is reconciled, for better or worse.

Also, Leorio is a god damn pervert.

This entry was posted in Hunter X Hunter. Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.

10 Comments

  1. Dawn
    Posted December 12, 2011 at 11:58 am | Permalink

    He didn’t have a bag ready exactly, he turned a the piece of Jone’s shirt into a bag.

    I just love it when Killua gave the heart back. It just screamed “Well I don’t need this anymore, you can it back now.”

    • Posted December 12, 2011 at 12:24 pm | Permalink

      lol, did he really grab a piece of the shirt? I guess he could have used the part he tore through to get the guy’s heart in the first place, but the hole on the shirt seemed kind of small LOL

      • Glossa Bingo
        Posted December 12, 2011 at 1:12 pm | Permalink

        Think of it like this: Killua would have needed to go through Johness’ shirt in order to pluck out his heart. He took part of Johness’ shirt alongside the heart in this adaptation–you can assume that the tears are matted down inside of Johness’ chest cavity…gross.

      • Posted December 12, 2011 at 2:47 pm | Permalink

        That is pretty gross, yes.

      • Posted December 12, 2011 at 3:16 pm | Permalink

        you can assume that the tears are matted down inside of Johness’ chest cavity…gross.

        Oh my god.

  2. Posted December 12, 2011 at 1:11 pm | Permalink

    After watching that clip of the older series, I have to say I think the newer one handed that scene much better. Badasses are far less interesting than psychopaths

    • Posted December 12, 2011 at 2:47 pm | Permalink

      Killua’s portrayal is something I go back and forth on in the original. It leaps back and forth between “he’s a badass” and “he’s a fucked up kid”, and it never really made much sense to me.

  3. mango
    Posted December 12, 2011 at 3:59 pm | Permalink

    I’m not sure I agree with you if only because I don’t see the heart ripping scene as funny at all…but I guess I get where you’re coming from…

    • Posted December 12, 2011 at 4:00 pm | Permalink

      Well, as can be gleaned from looking over my other blog entries, I do have a rather twisted sense of humor. :p

  4. Posted December 12, 2011 at 4:37 pm | Permalink

    But the funniest reaction of all is probably from Gon, who could not give less of a shit that his new best friend is a psychopathic murder, and immediately wants to pass the time with him by playing games. Gon, you are just as crazy as Killua.

    THIS. It’s like I don’t know WHO I’ll be safe with in this group. Probably Kurapika’s anyone’s best bet–unless you’re a spider.

    I like the black humor in HxH, and it’s nice to see it being highlighted a bit more in this remake.

  • PODCAST

    New Podcast next Tuesday, December 6, on Grimgar, Mob Psycho, Schwarzesmarken, and more! The more being mostly bickering
  • Categories

  • Anime

  • Latest MAL Articles