11 Comments /

First Impressions: Durarara, Ookami Kakushi, Hanamaru Kindergarden, Seikon no Quasar

So I’ve decided to change my first impres­sions post­ing slightly. Instead of wait­ing for 4 shows before mak­ing a post, I’m going to do a con­stant update with each show I watch, sim­ilar to Star Crossed. These first impres­sion posts were a blatant ripoff err, inspired by his format any­way so it makes more sense this way.

Dur­arara

Well I’ve covered the first epis­ode in detail already but let me take a step back a second and say that this epis­ode was no A-grade mater­ial. It wasn’t so much expos­i­tion sat­ur­a­tion as intro­du­cing explo­sion. With so much inform­a­tion being hurled at you in the first epis­ode, it was impossible to take it all in.

Still the best first epis­ode of the sea­son though. I said it before, but it’s when an epis­ode oozes qual­ity even when not that much is hap­pen­in­gon screen that you know you’ve got some­thing great on your hands. Bac­cano star­ted the exact same way and that worked fant­ast­ic­ally and Dur­arara­has a whole 24 epis­odes to start mak­ing sense in.

So yeah, Dur­ararar­agi (sorry, I stuttered) had obvi­ous qual­ity stamped on it before it aired and the first epis­ode has obvi­ous qual­ity stamped all over it too. I just hope none of these char­ac­ters are as pain­fully annoy­ing as Enjin from Yoza­k­ura Quar­tet. This show gives off sim­ilar vibes to Yoza­k­ura and I’d hate to see it ruined.

Rat­ing: B

Ookami Kak­ushi

I appear to be the last man in the uni­verse not to have seen Higur­ashi but from what I heard, the first epis­ode of that was very sim­ilar to how Ookamistar­ted. So I’m all for giv­ingthis the bene­fit of the doubt and con­tinu­ing on but that doesn’t change that this was a very poor episode.

The writ­ing was poor and it didn’t have the failsafe of being com­pletely OTT like Umineko to fall back on to provide enter­tain­ment so the epis­ode remained pretty dull through­out. The ‘char­ac­ter designs by Peach Pit’ that every­one was tout­ing turns out to be a neg­at­ive strike for this, I don’t like them one bit.

It was an all round very poor epis­ode. But hey, mys­tery and intrigue and what­not are being­touted along with the pos­sib­il­ity that they will all get bru­tally murdered. But things really need to pick up or I might bail on this show. For everything Deen did with Umineko, at least it was enter­tain­ing. This isn’t…yet.

Rat­ing: D+

Hanamaru Kinder­garden

I had a half-written post in my drafts where I lamen­ted the fact that an awful lot of anime made recently have ‘cute­ness’ as the main appeal, such as Kobato, K-ON and Kimi ni Todoke. Hanamaru fits straight into that cat­egory except…I actu­ally enjoyed this.

My pre­dic­tion of some­thing sim­ilar to a Yot­suba anime turned out to be right on the ball. This is the cute­ness and inno­cence of kids in a world where real adult prob­lems and lives exist, with their prob­lems and life­style being seen through the world of these kids. Gran­ted, Yot­suba does this a lot bet­ter but that’s a high stand­ard to be com­pared to.

The genu­ine adult prob­lems was actu­ally a bit of a shock. I cer­tainly didn’t expect any­thing like that at all, which goes to show there is a bit of brains behind this anime. It lacks the cut­ting ‘that’s so true’ edge at the moment but it’s a sur­pris­ingly enjoy­able way to spend 20 odd minutes.

Rat­ing: C+

Seikon no Quasar

You know the way every­one was hung up over the ‘breast-milk’ aspect of this show? Well, that’s actu­ally the best part of this show. There’s a creepy nature to the sexual con­tent in this show when com­bined with the Chris­tian­ity and I can actu­ally see poten­tial here and I’m will­ing to give it another epis­ode or two. But there’s so much it does wrong.

If you’re try­ing to sub­vert the sexual nature, you don’t then and go toss in blatant fanser­vi­ceas well. The entire suck­ling scene would’ve worked far bet­ter if prior to that scene I wasn’t treated to con­tinu­ous Gain­ax­ing, panty-flashes and prom­in­ent curves before­hand. If the sexual con­tent was played for plot rather than fanser­vice this would’ve worked a whole lot better.

What’s going to even­tu­ally be the killing blow is the anim­a­tion. Oh dear lord was it ter­rible. Ran­dom pan­ning shots, a scene of a char­ac­ter stand­ing per­fectly still for 5 seconds, a still frame of some­thing that doesn’t need to be still-framed and the occa­sional shot­where the art­work sud­denly col­lapsed. Cen­sor­ship galore and it’s pretty darn jarring.

::Edit:: Hmm…actually the only reason I’m giv­ing this a shot is because I found myself think­ing “it has fanser­vice so I’ll instantly dis­miss it” and then hated myself for doing that. I’m going to cast aside my elit­ism for a change and when I do drop this show, it will be for poor story-telling and plot. Not for boobs.

Rat­ing: C–

This entry was posted in First Impressions and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

10 Comments

  1. Posted January 9, 2010 at 10:25 pm | Permalink

    Hmm… I’ve already voiced my opin­ion on Dur­arara, but If Ookami’s any­thing like Higur­ashi I’ll watch it. But I might wait for another epis­ode to come out to see if it’s worth stick­ing with.

  2. luffyluffy
    Posted January 9, 2010 at 10:31 pm | Permalink

    Ookami Kak­ushi was so blantently like Higur­ashi that it actu­ally pissed me off… To me it hon­estly felt like Higur­ashi with dif­fer­ent, shit­tier char­ac­ters that arent even that good look­ing. I mean, before the chart, I had never even known that Ryukishi07 had done any­thing other than Higrashi and Umineko, so maybe The studio(AIC, right?) is attempt­ing to pounce on the “EVERYTHING RYUKISHI07 DOES IS GODLY” non­sense being spewed out…

  3. Béla
    Posted January 10, 2010 at 10:50 am | Permalink

    I haven’t seen Higur­ashi, so that makes us two. But con­sid­er­ing Ookami Kak­ushi wasn’t that really bad (expect the main char­ac­ters voice act­ing, the tons of dull loli/shota-kids and the bor­ing first epis­ode) and as I’ve heard in Higur­ashi the story retakes in a new view, or some­thing like that in every 4 epis­ode, or so I think they can actu­ally man­age to pull this out in a good way. And we should watch Higur­ashi meanwhile.

  4. Scamp
    Posted January 10, 2010 at 7:15 pm | Permalink

    @Siri

    Ah the glory of not being as obsessed with anime as I am. You get to read reviews and then NOT watch the crap

    @luffyluffy

    The reason I think AIC were chosen was because Deen appar­ently did a crappy job of adapt­ing Umineko. Maybe RYUKISHI07 and his people decided they didn’t want Deen adapt­ing his other works.

    @Béla

    I’m actu­ally going to wait for Ookami Kak­ushi to fin­ish (or altern­at­ively, when I get bored of it) before I even con­sider watch­ing Higur­ashi. Don’t want to watch two shows so sim­ilar at once

  5. luffyluffy
    Posted January 10, 2010 at 8:28 pm | Permalink

    Hmm.. I guess that can be seen.. Though I hon­estly enjoyed Umineko.. Though it still stands that I’ve never even heard of this VN before, and it hon­estly feels like a damned Higur­ashi rewrite:

    Ookami Kak­ushi:
    The story fol­lows Hiroshi Kuzumi, a 16-year-old boy who has just moved to the seem­ingly serene vil­lage of Jogama­chi. Nestled in the moun­tains far away from the city, the vil­lage is divided by a river that sep­ar­ates old Jogama­chi from new Jogama­chi. Young Hiroshi soon dis­cov­ers that the village’s ancient as well as mys­ter­i­ous tra­di­tions and cus­toms have been kept alive over the ages. Although a bit bewildered by the new envir­on­ment, Hiroshi begins to settle into his new life. While he has never been the type to win any pop­ular­ity con­tests, he quickly earns the affec­tion of his class­mates. That is with the excep­tion of aloof class pres­id­ent, Nemuru Kush­in­ada, whose only words to Hiroshi are a warn­ing to stay away from old part of town. It is there that ter­ror and mys­tery await him.

    Higur­ashi no Naku Koro Ni:
    After mov­ing into the quiet town of Hin­am­iz­awa, Mae­bara Keii­chi spends his days bliss­fully in school often play­ing games with his local friends. How­ever, appear­ances can be deceiv­ing. One fate­ful day, Keii­chi stumbles upon news of a murder that had occurred in Hin­am­iz­awa. From this point on, hor­rific events unfold in front of Keii­chi, as he soon learns his close friends may not be all that they seem. Based on the ama­teur mys­tery game by 7th Expan­sion, the story is told in a series of dif­fer­ent scenarios.

    Plus… Just in series sim­u­lar­it­ies are jar­ring. Though, I guess I’m being overly hard on the series..

  6. luffyluffy
    Posted January 11, 2010 at 12:33 pm | Permalink

    HNNNGGG, DOUBLE POST *shot*

    Hanamaru Kinder­garten for me is pretty much best of the sea­son, the entire epis­ode had me laugh­ing, and well.… THEYRE ALL SO KYOOOTTTT~! Cant. wait. for. epis­ode. two.

    Scuse me while I go hump stu­dio Gainax’s leg

  7. Poro
    Posted January 11, 2010 at 5:05 pm | Permalink

    YES! someone agrees with me! watch­able but not as epic as expected

  8. Scamp
    Posted January 11, 2010 at 9:39 pm | Permalink

    @luffyluffy

    Yeah, as I’ve learned in the past, cute­ness loses its appeal very quickly for me. I’m a bit wary with Hanamaru

    @Poro

    Bac­cano star­ted the same way so I’m not too worried

  9. Faye_Zhoa
    Posted January 13, 2010 at 11:17 am | Permalink

    Dur­arara 1st epis­ode still not clearly (well, maybe it’s still the begin­ning), but i’m still lookin’ for­ward to it, two thumbs up for the motor­cycle part, that was cool~!

    And for Ookami kak­ushi, well, the main char­ac­ter like a girl for me, too ‘moe’ for a guy, and a lil’ bit like lelouch?

  10. Scamp
    Posted January 13, 2010 at 5:04 pm | Permalink

    @Faye_Zhoa

    You mean the lead guy of Ookami is the cart driver!!!!!!

One Trackback

  1. By ookami kakushi episode one « Bokutachi no BLOG on January 12, 2010 at 10:08 pm

    […] I didn’t know what to write. And con­tinu­ing in the same line of hon­esty, I even checked out what Scamp (and a few oth­ers) thought before sit­ting down and think­ing again what I should write. In the end, […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

  • Twitter

  • Categories

  • Anime

  • Archives

  • Other blog stuff